Meet the Chefs: Matt McPherson of Matt's Red Rooster

July 31, 2014 1 Comment

Unionville's Phil Moran interviews the chefs at our outlets and restaurant clients. These pieces are not intended to be restaurant reviews. Rather, they showcase the relationships we have with others in the local food and wine industry. 

This first piece highlights the longstanding relationship we have with Matt McPherson of Matt's Red Rooster in Flemington. We enjoy working with Matt and others who appreciate the value of fine wine, good food, and great meals shared with friends and family. 

 ~Stacy Brody, Operations Coordinator, Unionville Vineyards


When Flemington native Matt McPherson came home to open his own restaurant Matt's Red Rooster Grill, his intention was not to create a great grill room. Like most CIA (Culinary Institute of America) graduates, Matt’s grounding was in classical sauces, nouveau and French techniques. His intention was to bring those refinements to his hometown.

At that time, ten years ago, Flemington was a thriving center of discount shopping (a business now eviscerated by the growth of the internet). Although white tablecloth, American and Italian cuisine, was already thriving, the world of “sauciers” and cuisine focused on sauté specialties hadn't penetrated rural West Jersey. Matt, who had honed his skills with the great Chef Ed Brown in the “Sea Grill” in Rockefeller Center, planned to build on that experience. He anticipated sautéing the finest fish, veal and local vegetables, then crisping those creations in a high heat oven and imparting a light wood smoke nose and flavor.

In Matt’s words, what we know today as “Matt’s Red Rooster”(an American Grill Room) and the area's unquestioned source of the finest grilled chops, aged steaks and quickly charred fish, was a serendipitous creation.

When I was planning the restaurant, I spent a week in Seattle with the intention of purchasing a wood fired oven. I wanted a wood oven for the very high heat I needed to quickly crisp, glaze and finish the dishes I envisioned. I stayed for a week and cooked with all the manufacturer’s equipment lines in their test kitchen. It was only after I had the opportunity to work on their high end wood fired grill that I realized this was what my cuisine needed.

It took some time and experimentation with the grill to get exactly what I wanted. I now burn a mix of oak, apple and cherry wood. At the Rooster, we go through 3-4 cords of wood each week.

Matt tells us although he is the first professional chef in the family, cooking at home was an event, not a chore, an event in which the entire family participated. My father was regularly behind the stove, cooking  not just for the family but for the Flemington Elks and in charitable events.

For Dad, “cooking for others was his way of dealing with stress.”

By the time Matt was 16, he knew he wanted to become a chef. Matt enrolled in the culinary program at Hunterdon Central H.S., and Gary Peabody, the head of the program became a mentor. At that time we were not all pushed towards obtaining a college degree. I thought I could complete high school and get started on my career. Mr. Peabody had other ideas. He took me up to CIA knowing before I did that there was more to this business than just practicing in front of a stove.

CIA was a turning point for Matt. In the first two years the curriculum was entirely culinary arts. By the time those two years were over, I knew how much I didn’t know and stayed another two years to obtain a B.S. in Restaurant Management.

After school, Matt moved to NYC to increase his skills with the highest level of talent. He was recruited by Chef Ed Brown to re-open the Sea Grill in Rockefeller Center. I learned a lot at the Sea Grill: how to design and fit out a restaurant, hiring, training and motivating staff and a million other things. Ed Brown is a master motivator as well as a great chef.  From the beginning my compensation package was tied to the number of stars we received from the major reviewers. Living in NYC, I needed every penny of a four star bonus. The key to that bonus was not only brilliance but consistency with every dish, every night. That is not easy, particularly when you are delivering 500 covers an evening.

That training, that learning, (if not the 500 covers in this 90 seat restaurant) shows at the Red Rooster.

Although the basic concept is grilling the finest beef, chops and fish, the “saucier” comes through, as there may be as many as six sauces available each night.

As Karla Cook noted in her New York Times review:  Standout appetizers included an appealingly fragile pan-fried crab cake with a sweet roasted red pepper rémoulade; a composition of roasted red and golden beets with goat cheese and a balsamic-chive drizzle; and an intense mushroom soup with a base of chicken stock enriched and brimming with roasted wild mushrooms and a touch of cream. Another treat was the wood-fired romaine heart, its tender exterior yielding to crunch and smoothed with a parmesan dressing, a smattering of grated parmesan and the lingering flavor of wood smoke.

Other favorites were a Griggstown Farm charcuterie platter that hit all the right notes with its grilled chicken-apple sausage, house-made truffled chicken liver pâté and slim slices of Manchego cheese; and the poblano pepper stuffed with pulled pork (the source of that outdoor aroma, perhaps) in a delightfully gloppy pool of aged Cheddar, salsa and a lime-sparked sour cream.

The Artful Diner’s review focused more on the entrées available on the night of their visit: Entrées highlight Mr. McPherson's love affair with the grill. And should you entertain a passion for finny fare, the grilled whole fish of the day  (branzino during my two most recent visits) -- which may be served intact or filleted in the kitchen -- is clearly the way to go. The skin is crisp and crackling, the flesh marvelously moist, and the accompanying lemon caper butter stunning in its simplicity. The grilled scallops, a daily special, were also quite nice....

The pork chop roulade is another winner. The meat is pounded thin then rolled with provolone, Swiss, and mixed herbs and grilled to tender perfection. The consummating touch is a heady mushroom Marsala sauce.

Lovers of red meat, of course, also have some very appetizing choices: rib-eye steak with cabernet demi-glace for instance, or peppercorn-encrusted New York strip with tarragon shallot butter. … I opted for the filet mignon. Velvety of texture and grilled to a mouthwatering medium rare, you will find the accompanying blue cheese sauce vividly assertive but not overpowering.

Matt is also a true believer in the power of fine wine to elevate great cooking. didn't really have a background in wine appreciation until my years at CIA. In school I took a series of wine courses as part of the curriculum. After graduating I went to Napa for 40 days in the dessert, cooking and tasting the finest California wines. It’s funny, I had absorbed a lot in school and in Napa, but I was really just a cork-dork.  I didn't get it until I was able to spend a few afternoons at Unionville listening to Cam rhapsodize about the power of fine wine to compliment and even enhance the power of food. That was my “lightbulb over the head” moment.

To this day, ten years after meeting Cam and being introduced to Unionville, Matt remains amazed at the quality of Unionville wines he is able to offer in the Rooster. My overall favorite is the 2010 “Big O”. The power and elegance of that Bordeaux blend is a perfect foil to the finest steaks and chops.

I asked Matt for a recipe to share with the Unionville faithful, and he provided the following recipe for Creamy Parmesan Dressing for his Grilled Romaine, the only dish always on the menu at the Rooster and for Matt the only dish “ I’m sure I've got right”.

Creamy Parmesan Dressing

2 T Dijon mustard
1 Anchovy filet
1-2 garlic cloves
1/2 c shallots
1/4 c olive oil
2 egg yolks 
(1/4 c of mayonnaise as a substitute for the oil and eggs)
Pinch of salt

Combine above ingredients in food processor or blender. Season to taste. When refrigerated, can last up to one week. Serve with grilled romaine or as alternative to Caesar dressing. Also great for a bread or vegetable dip. 


1 Response


April 22, 2017

this is my sister’s favorite dish at the restaurant. Thanks for the recipe, however isn’t there supposed to be parmesan somewhere in there?

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in Unionville Grapevine

It's our 25th Anniversary and I'm not sure what to say
It's our 25th Anniversary and I'm not sure what to say

September 04, 2018

Today, we are picking the first grapes for what is Unionville's 27th harvest. Two years after the first grapes were picked and fermented, they were sold in the newly-opened tasting room- 25 years ago. Although I've been thinking about this moment for about a year, we've started our anniversary celebration and I'm still struggling to put it all in context. 

In the past few years I've learned so much that could be shared with you now. I've spent hours at the township building, reading through letters written back and forth between parties involved in the winery's founding in the early 1990's. I've walked the vineyards, pausing with each "King of the Vineyard" as Conor calls them- the craggy, gnarly vines nearly as old as me. I've stared at the black and white photos in the hallway of the 1858 Farmhouse of the family and workers who tended to this property many decades ago.

View full article →

Unionville Vineyards Port Wine
Winter is coming and so is Port wine

November 20, 2017

It’s the most wonderful time of the year! I know that is cliché to say, but it truly is a great time at Unionville. We’ve got all of our reds pressed and in barrel. Cooler, stainless-steel fermentations are finishing up in tank, I’m finally able to breathe a little easier, and wake up a little later. With the holidays upon us, the wine making team has a lot on the mind, but one thing standing out is the blending, bottling, and release of Vat #23 – the latest rendition of our opulent Port wine. 

Port has a storied history at Unionville – the fortified delight has been made at the winery since its first vintage in 1993, Before we delve into that, we have to talk a little about how Port is made and the different styles in which it can be presented. Port, named for its origin country, Portugal, is typically a sweet or medium-dry red wine, fortified with distilled grape spirit, then cellared and bottled at different times and in different ways to present specific stylizations. The two most recognizable presentations of Port wine are Ruby and Tawny Ports. Ruby styles are young wines usually aged for only a couple of years (or less). They’re released early to showcase juicy acidity and fruity characteristics of young wine with fuller mouthfeel and complexity

View full article →

Unionville Vineyard Rose'
Robert Parker's Wine Advocate: The Results

September 13, 2017 1 Comment

Since I started at Unionville 5 years ago, it has always been a goal to have our wines evaluated by top critics. In the years since, John Foy at the Star-Ledger has called our wines "Napa worthy," and Stuart Pigott, who freelances for James Suckling and Wine Business Monthly wrote that our Syrah was the best expression of the grape in the United States. T.J. Foderaro at Inside Jersey Magazine, Alan Richman (Saveur), Robin Shreeves (Cherry Hill Courier-Post), Rosie Saferstein (NJ Monthly), and the Trenton Times' Susan Yeske have all added their voices to the coalition of the willing in the last couple of years.

Having Unionville in the pages of one of the major wine magazines had remained elusive, until last summer when Mark Squires, East Coast wine critic for the Wine Advocate sat down and tasted...

View full article →


Sign up to be the first to hear about our events!